After posting Dutch’s pic’s (“Extreme Retrieving”), some replies (Blog & Facebook) included comments about risks of choking. I had never allowed Dutch to play with tennis balls alone, and only use them outside under supervision. Unfortunately, that only gives you the opportunity to possibly save your dog if the ball lodges in the back of his mouth, or worse! All my old tennis balls are going into the garbage. As you can see in those pics, Dutch is a very large dog, and anything under 3 1/2 ” in diameter is risky. The only smaller balls we’ll use will be rope balls. Thanks to all who cautioned me about this!!! See story, below:
This warning is something all owners of large breed dogs should give consideration to, especially if you have a Ball-Crazy German Shepherd, Golden Retriever or Labrador.
TENNIS BALLS ARE NOT SAFE FOR BIG DOGS
While I was talking on the phone, Sailor my 10-month-old German Shepherd brought me his ball for a game of indoor catch. It was a hard rubber ball about tennis ball size. It had little raised dots of rubber. I was quite sure it was too large for there to be any danger of him swallowing it. I would toss it to him and he’d catch it on the fly. We must have done it thirty times when suddenly I looked at Sailor and saw that he was in great distress. I knew instantly that he must have gotten the ball stuck in his throat on the last toss. His head was down and he was trying to get it out but was unable to do so. I dropped the phone not even taking one second to explain to the caller what was happening. I grabbed my dog and he wriggled free struggling to get air and free himself of the object lodged in his throat. I was wrestling him in his own fight for survival.
Three times I grabbed him and three times he got away from me. Finally I got him and pried open his mouth. Trying to get the ball out with my fingers only seemed to cause it to slide further down in his throat. The poor animal was struggling to be free of me and to get air into his lungs again. The ball was now in his throat beyond reach, like an enormous Adam’s apple. He had locked his teeth and was trying to swallow it. And of course he could not. By this time I am as desperate and frantic as he is. I live on the fifteenth floor of a pre-war building in mid- Manhattan. There is no vet in the building and none of my neighbors are at home. I know that by the time the elevator operator puts down his newspaper and saunters into the elevator and brings the old machine up 15 stories my beloved young dog will be near death. And then to go down again and try to find a cab that would take me and the dog to a vet or the Animal Medical Center… well, no creature on earth could go for that length of time without air and make it.
Never have I felt more alone and scared then I did at that moment. I knew that if I couldn’t figure out how to save him and do it quickly he was going to die. I grabbed onto him again, straddling him. I put my hand below the ball on the outside of his neck and gently worked the ball up his throat the way you would work a ball through a tube or out of the toe of a sock. It came up part way, but then Sailor reeled away again in his panic and struggle. I grabbed him again and threw him on the couch, again half straddling him to try and hold him. His teeth were clamped down, I seemed to need at least four hands and I only had two. I remember telling God I needed his help RIGHT NOW! I knew that time was running out and the thought of my beautiful young dog dying in my arms while I am powerless to help him gave me a feeling of despair I’d never known before. Again I tried to work the ball up his throat from the outside by squeezing it gently from beneath. Slowly but surely it rose up his throat. I pried his teeth open with my fingers and finally, holding his head against me and keeping one hand under the ball, I was able to reach into his mouth and grab the ball from the back of his throat and pull it out.
We sat there for a long time. He kept swallowing and was very quiet. Young as he was he seemed to know how close to death he had come. There was a fair amount of blood on my fingers and I wasn’t sure whether it had come from his throat. I thought that perhaps his throat was tom so I took him to the vet immediately. The vet checked him out and found him to be okay, but gave him some antibiotics just in case. He told me that I had saved my dog’s life. Most people, he said, try to get help and the dog dies on the way. They just can’t get to help fast enough to save their dog. Usually, he said, when I see them they are already dead. I see a lot of golden retrievers with tennis balls that have died on the way.
Most of the blood had, I found out later, come from my own fingers that had taken a bit of a beating prying open those clamped sharp baby molars. My fingers were sore for days, but who cared, I had my dog and he was alive! I started to warn other owners of big ball-happy dogs in Central Park. Some would respond with, “But he’s never swallowed it before.” Yes, well the first time could be the LAST time. It only takes one time for your dog to die. He may have caught it for years and then one day he catches it on the fly and it gets beyond his tongue and you can lose your dog.
Three weeks later a friend’s German shepherd got a tennis ball caught in his throat. The dog is seven years old and has been retrieving tennis balls for years. It happened in Central Park and the NYPD happened to be close by and threw the dog in the patrol car and raced (sometimes literally over the sidewalk) to get it to the Animal Medical Center.
The dog was blue and almost gone when they pulled up at the Animal Medical Center. “What did they do?” I asked, expecting to hear about quick major surgery. “Oh, they just worked it up his throat from the outside and it popped right out!” said his owner. So why doesn’t anyone tell owners about this? Everyone thinks that a tennis ball is safe. TENNIS BALLS ARE NOT SAFE FOR BIG DOGS.
I have heard that the Heimlich maneuver can be used to expel something lodged in a dog’s throat. I don’t know whether it was a method that might have worked. It is probably good to know as well. But I do know that a major animal hospital used the same method of working it up from the outside that I described. I think big dog owners should know this. Obviously one doesn’t take animal medicine into one’s own hands when there is a vet at one’s elbow. But when your dog is for sure going to die if YOU don’t DO something then it is good to know something you can do.- Last week I heard that another Central Park dog died the same way. His owner tried to get the dog from the park into a cab and to a vet and he didn’t make it.
That’s why I wanted to share this, because many people are so panicked that they don’t think to even try to work the ball up from the outside. I thought perhaps this might save a dog’s life. Now all Sailor’s balls are rope balls. They are tennis ball sized but there is a rope attached. One mail order company even sells ones that float. And the rope enables me to throw them further and Sailor gets a longer run.
I let Fenris play with a tennis ball once and only once (because it happened to be the only thing around). It was pretty clear when it was in his mouth how small it was.
I’ve also been generally leery about tennis balls for dogs. I had heard from someone (possibly from this blog and I kind of want to say it was Carole. If I’m wrong, I’m sorry for throwing you under the bus) that the glue that’s on tennis balls will eat away at the enamel on a dog’s teeth.
Regarding the glue, that was something I had posted almost 2 years ago! You must have a memory like a steel trap! I have been only using the tennis balls for supervised play, and only a couple of times a day outside. We brush his pearly-whites almost daily. But, after reading this article, even my tennis bag will be kept zipped to prevent potential access to a ball. Do you think that the 3″ orbee’s are dangerous, too? I’m thinking I should only throw larger toys like big chuckits, jolly balls, golf frisbee discs, etc. This is SO SCARY!!!
I’m the nervous dog parent. Prove to me that something is bad for the pup and I’ll avoid it as best as possible.
Personal opinion: bigger toys are better. Even if you have to walk away for just a second, you don’t have to worry about the dog choking on it.
Plus (at least with Fenris) large awkward toys mean the dog uses more energy trying to get it, put it in their mouths, drag it around to play with, etc.
I’ll usually browse the toys at the pet store to figure out the right size before I end up buying the toy online.
Beverly, thank you very much for posting this.
The Large Orbee is 4.5″ they also sometimes offer an XL. The robe balls are replaced at no charge if they are chewed up.
http://www.planetdog.com/ProductInfo.aspx?productid=ORBEE%20BALL
Chuck it has a new ball out that Andrea W. brought to the schutzhund trial as a raffle prize…I so wanted to win it, but that is another story…
It is called “Kick Fetch” made by Chuck It
It is the size of a soccer ball but has grooves into the ball that make it easy to grab.
http://www.chewy.com/dog/chuckit-kick-fetch-ball/dp/49717
My kids strip the planets off the balls:(
My friend, a veterinarian, told me about a Golden Retriever that came into her clinic that had a tennis ball stuck in its throat. It ended up dying because they could not get it dislodged. I asked if they attempted a tracheotomy below the ball to give the dog an open airway and I got a very dumb look. Fortunately this hasn’t happened before at that clinic, but they didn’t know what to do. Hopefully they’ll know in the future.
On a side note, I watched as my horse choked on a hay cube and I felt extremely helpless because I had no idea how to help him, especially since he’s so large. Fortunately he was able to cough it up on his own. Very scary and no more hay cubes for him.
That happened to one of my horses too and it got stuck. The vet had to come out and move it with a NG tube-very scary.
I agree with all of the above. My girls will try to grab the handballs out of my husbands gym bag if given the chance. They are hard rubber and 2 1/4 ” in diameter. The gym bag lives on the laundry room shelf now, not on the floor. They also will find golf balls at the park and it scares the you know what out of me til I get them back. They like to play keep away with each other once one of them finds a treasure and I can easily see one of those getting stuck in an instant.
I will have to check out the Chuckit kick and fetch since Libby and Ziva are very deprived and have so few toys-LOL. I wonder if it is easier on the teeth than a jolly ball? Ziva started wearing down her canines, so I have greatly limited her access to it.
Chuckit also makes and extra large whister ball and a launcher to go with it:)
I always hang my tennis bag up on a hook in the closet because I didn’t want Dutch to take my “good” balls. Now, I have an even more important reason! The Chuck-it thrower came with a tennis ball, but in bright colors. It was exactly the same size as a tennis ball, which is why tennis balls fit in it. I don’t recall reading any warning about using it with large dogs. It is so dangerous!